The Renewal of the Royal New Zealand Navy Fleet
Senior Fellow Peter Greener enlarged his discussion on the renewal of the Royal New Zealand Navy Fleet for the future.
The broader picture
From December 2025, when Navy Lookout asked, “New Zealand’s frigate choice: Mogami or Type 31?” there has been ongoing international interest in which new frigate New Zealand will choose. Public debate has been almost solely focused on replacing New Zealand’s two Anzac frigates, but the purchase of the frigates is only the beginning of a comprehensive renewal of the ships (and uncrewed systems) of the Royal New Zealand Navy. No one it seems is debating FLEET renewal.
An industry engagement invitation which was issued by the Ministry of Defence in 2023 highlighted that most of the Royal New Zealand Navy fleet would reach the end of their service life by the mid-2030s. It sought expressions of interest for capabilities which would provide naval combat, maritime security, sealift and humanitarian aid and disaster relief (HADR), Southern Ocean and Polar patrol, and Littoral Operations.
These capabilities are currently provided by the two Anzac frigates HMNZS Te Kaha and HMNZS Te Mana, along with two offshore patrol vessels (OPVs), HMNZS Otago and HMNZS Wellington, the multi-role vessel HMNZS Canterbury and maritime sustainment vessel HMNZS Aotearoa. Some maritime security tasks remain with the two Inshore Patrol Vessels HMNZS Hawea and HMNZS Taupo. In ten years’ time, only HMNZS Aotearoa will still have useful operational life left.
One of the imperatives in the Industry Engagement - Maritime Fleet Market Research, was that future fleet design should seek to ease the training burden, and make maintenance easier. “This may be achieved through having more of the same class of ship and greater commonality of systems across the fleet.”
When I put these requirements to former Joint Force Headquarters Commander Rear Admiral (Retired) Jim Gilmour ONZM, he responded, “If less differences in our ships is important, and it is, then when and how is the move to commonality accomplished? It makes sense to build what comes next with a view to what comes after that. One decision criteria for the Frigate replacement might consider the ability for systems from that ship to be integrated into the next renewal acquisition. Could that be an LPD?” (Landing Platform Dock, a vessel which could operate in a wider range of sea states than Canterbury.)
Of note here was the intent stated in the previous Defence Capability Plan 2019 to purchase an enhanced sealift vessel to work alongside Canterbury, in order to increase New Zealand’s capacity to respond to events in the South Pacific. The Plan noted that,
“While a future project will determine detailed requirements for this capability, a Landing Platform Dock is an example of the type of vessel that will be considered.”
Whilst no decision on a further heavy lift vessel was subsequently pursued, HMNZS Canterbury will need to be replaced before the end of the next decade.
The functions of the Offshore Patrol Vessels will also need to be replaced.
The frigate decision
The long awaited 2025 Defence Capability Plan, released on 7 April 2025, made it very clear that New Zealand was to align itself much more closely with Australia. Ultimately the New Zealand Defence Force was to be not only interoperable with its Australian counterparts, but should also be able to integrate with Australian Forces.
The 2025 DCP also commits New Zealand to improving defence cooperation and interoperability with its Five Eyes partners.
In May this year then Defence Minister Chris Penk emphasised this when announcing that, “Our decision to prioritise discussions with our partners and focus on considering the Japanese Mogami-class frigate selected by Australia and the UK’s Type 31 frigates to inform the business case reflects our need to be interoperable and leverage efficiencies.” He went on to add that, “A final decision has not yet been made, and advice is expected to be provided to Cabinet before the end of 2027.”
Of particular significance were the observations in the 2025 DCP that New Zealand should ask what the Australian approach is and is there any reason for New Zealand to take a different approach? New Zealand and Australia are “committed to prioritising combined defence procurement as an enabler of interoperability.” New Zealand would therefore “seek to procure the same assets and equipment as Australia where it makes sense to do so.”
Given those imperatives it might seem that an Australian-specification Mogami may be the obvious choice. But it may not be. Much has been made of replacing the two current frigates, and both British and Japanese designs are strong contenders but for different reasons. Both frigates are big ships, almost twice the size of the current Anzac frigates.
The enhanced Mogami comes as an almost fully-fitted warship. It has the ability to provide air defence as well as land and maritime strike. It has a stealth hull with a low acoustic signature. It comes with a strong anti-submarine warfare (ASW) capability, with a sophisticated towed-array sonar and onboard torpedoes. And it requires a smaller crew of 92, against 110 for the Type 31. For comparison, an Anzac frigate requires a crew of 178.
The Type 31 was considered initially as a “fitted for but not with” ship in order to keep the price down to a level of GBP250 million. Weapons were to be government furnished and their cost was not included in the initial pricing.
As the threat environment in the Northern Hemisphere has grown, so to have the range of armaments considered for fitting to Type 31. The Type 31 can now be configured to carry the Sea Ceptor air-defence weapon system; the Naval Strike Missile; and up to 32 Mk41 VLS capable of launching a variety of missiles. The ship would be reliant on an embarked maritime helicopter for anti-submarine capability; in New Zealand’s case that would be one of the five highly capable Sikorsky MH-60R Seahawks that have been ordered.
Both the Mogami and Type 31 have been designed to carry uncrewed systems, allowing for the further development of a hybrid navy. The Type 31 though has significantly more space provided for future needs.
The economic argument
With the fitting of upgraded weapon systems, Navy Outlook on 24 July 2026 estimated that GBP400 million, about NZ$920 million, is now considered to be the approximate cost of a Type 31 Frigate, a ship with a displacement of 5,700 tons .
On 17 November 2023 Naval Technology estimated the completed cost of a Japanese Mogami frigate as US$453 million, or approximately NZ$765 million. However this is for a ship of 3,900 tons displacement. The Australia-specification Mogami will be 4,800 tons and therefore will be more expensive.
Given that the Type 31s were originally designed to be “fitted for but not with” it does raise the question as to whether the Sea Ceptor and forthcoming Naval Strike Missiles of the Anzac frigates could be transferred, leading to some initial equipment savings should the Type 31 be chosen.
Of more importance than the unit-cost per ship though, is the potential opportunity cost involved. On 2 July The British High Commission in New Zealand posted that “partnering on future frigates and advanced systems, some potentially homegrown in NZ, will deliver real value. With up to 1,000 jobs and $300m investment on offer for NZ’s maritime ecosystem, this is about mutual prosperity and security.”
How much the total value of work on the frigates will generate in New Zealand, be they British-built or Australian-built, cannot yet be clearly quantified. What is indisputable though is the enormous amount of benefit that New Zealand gained by contributing to the original Anzac frigate programme.
The Anzac frigate programme generated a significant amount of debate in New Zealand, not least because of the cost – ultimately NZ$1.22 billion for the two frigates. However, by the end of the build, the total value of work awarded to New Zealand firms was in excess of some NZ$800 million. New Zealand also gained immeasurably in terms of technological and industrial development.
In order to ensure that the New Zealand defence industry can further grow and develop, in October 2025 the New Zealand Defence Industry Strategy was released. International prime suppliers must develop and submit a NZ Industry Capability Plan, that will ensure that NZ industry will be used to deliver defence capability.
Bearing in mind that it is fleet replacement that is being considered, can the British match or beat the Australians or the Japanese on both ship type, price and industrial opportunity?
Future fleet composition
Two days following the release of the Defence Policy and Strategy Statement 2023, when asked directly by Jack Tame of TVNZ about the replacement of the frigates, the then Defence Minister Andrew Little Minister said “We have two frigates at the moment…The question is, is what we’ve got enough to equip us for what the future might hold?”
This had been brought home forcefully in the NZDF Annual Report for 2020-21 where, under the heading Performance Measures and Standards, the response for Naval Combat is “no capability” for both 2020 and 2021. Both ships were unavailable.
Writing in the Winter 2025 issue of Line of Defence Magazine, former RNZN Officer Andrew Watts highlighted that operational research had repeatedly demonstrated that a minimum of three ships were needed to ensure the reasonable availability of one fully effective ship at any given time.
Cost will ultimately be a consideration, but could either Mogami or Type 31provide two fully fitted frigates, with one ‘fitted for but not with’? This would provide an opportunity to up-arm the third if circumstances dictated it.
Whether two or three frigate hulls be bought, consideration needs to be given to ascertain whether the operating system is then suitable for the rest of the fleet. There are few illustrations of system commonality across different ship classes. The Type 31 has the TACTICOS combat management system (CMS). Whilst not fitted to the R.N. River-class OPVs, it is fitted to the Khareef-class variant of the Royal Navy of Oman. If it is decided that two offshore patrol vessels are needed, could they have the same operating system as a Type 31? Might that system then be suitable for a future heavy lift ship?
As for the Mogami, on April 20th of this year writing in The Diplomat, Takahashi Kosuke
drew attention to the potential complexity for Australia in integrating different weapons from the Japanese into the Mogami’s OYQ-1 combat management system. However, should New Zealand choose the Mogami, it is likely that any integration difficulties will have been overcome by the time New Zealand’s ships are built. Would the Mogami systems then be suitable for fitting across the rest of the fleet?
A future Navy comprised of three frigates, two offshore patrol vessels and one (or two?) heavy lift ships with common systems, plus HMNZS Aotearoa, would provide New Zealand with a real breadth and depth of capability.
In 2019, when interviewing then Rear Admiral James Gilmour, Commander Joint Forces New Zealand, he made the following observation:
“As an operational commander I am aware that quantity can have a quality of its own – it is not ideal to have the latest highest tech that is not available due to the small numbers of them that can be afforded.” In the current strategic environment, the delivery of only two frigate hulls in the fleet could significantly hinder New Zealand’s future ability to act as it might wish.
It is important to remember that these new ships will still be operational in forty years’ time. Which combination of ship types, support services and industrial opportunities will suit New Zealand’s needs best over this extended period? What will provide the best strategic, military, political, and economic outcomes? Perhaps by the end of 2027 we shall have some of the answers.
This is an updated version of the article on the Post.
Peter Greener is an Honorary Professor, and was previously Academic Dean at the Command and Staff College of the New Zealand Defence Force. He is Senior Fellow in the Center for Strategic Studies at the Victoria University of Wellington.